Featured Article:

$46 Million Dollar Award Causes Stir in Martial Arts Community

Jack Greener, a white belt Jiu Jitsu student, suffered a devasting, paralyzing injury while working with his black belt instructor. The injury was suffered in November, 2018 and the award was announced by the trial court on March 38, 2023. The California Superior Court handed down the decision after a long trial.

A major issue in the trial was whether the actions of the instructor involved negligence or gross negligence. Two key questions the jury was asked to answer were: “Was [Instructor’s] conduct a substantial factor in causing harm to Jack Greener?”   and “Did [Instructor] unreasonably increase the risk to Jack Greener over and above those inherent in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu sparring?”

The jury answered yes to both questions. In addition, expert testimony said that the technique fell outside the normal bounds of sparring and was abnormally dangerous.

The award includes money for past and future pain and suffering; money for past and future medical expenses; and money for future lost earnings.

At this time the case has not yet been published, but you can learn more (including details about how the injury occurred) by going to the following link:


It is interesting to note that there was no mention of a liability waiver or release in any of the reports.

Photo Credit: Thanks to Mark Bonica.

Read the Article

Recent Articles:

Unsupervised Childcare Costs Club’s Parent Company $13 Million

This article appeared in the Jan/Feb 2023 issue of Athletic Business. Attorney John Wolohan ([email protected]) is a professor of sports law in the David B. Falk College for Sport and Human Dynamics at Syracuse University, where Beth Perez is a Ph.D. student in Higher Education. Anyone who offers childcare in a fitness setting should pay special attention to this article. The reader should also note that there is no mention of a liability waiver in the article so one can only suppose that there was no waiver required.... [read more]

Hey!!! A Free Webinar: Learn More About Fitness Law

  By JoAnn Eickhoff-Shemek Teaching Fitness Law – FREE Webinar May 4th The Fitness Law Academy, LLC is again offering a Faculty Training Course this summer (begins May 23rd). Faculty members who have participated in this course the past two summers have enjoyed and benefited from the course. Many of them are now including legal/risk management content in an existing academic course or have developed an entire legal/risk management course which they are now teaching.... [read more]

Enforceability and Ambiguity at Issue in Kentucky Horseback Riding Waiver

By Doyice Cotten Ms. Sylvia Rieff and her two children visited Jesse James Riding Stables, Inc. (JJStables) and took a guided horseback riding tour. Approximately 20 minutes into the tour, as the trail entered the surrounding woods, Ms. Rieff’s saddle became loose, and she slid off the side of the horse, falling to the ground. Ms. Rieff sued JJStables alleging they were negligent in adjusting the saddle (Rieff v. Jesse James Riding Stables, Inc.,... [read more]

Waiver Protects in California Ab Coaster Waiver Case

By Doyice Cotten Lataya Young was working out on an Ab Coaster (not pictured) at a Planet Fitness when a weight landed on her foot.  Apparently a weight had fallen from the machine while she performed repetitions.  She had previously signed the following waiver of liability: “I understand and expressly agree that my use of this Planet Fitness facility involves the risk of injury to me, whether caused by me or not. I understand that these risks are inherent in physical activity and my use of the facilities,... [read more]

Early Warning Sign for Alzheimer’s: Your Vision

By Doyice Cotten Greetings, Some time ago, I shared with you some important material about aging and the risk of falls. It was sent to me by Jullieth Cragwell. https://www.sportwaiver.com/safety-for-aging-adults-great-ways-to-reduce-risks-of-falls-for-seniors/? I hope it was of benefit to some of you and hope some of you will find this of value. We all know how important it is to recognize the symptoms of Alzheimer’s early. Today I am sending more information that also comes to me from Jullieth Cragwell.... [read more]

#1 Function of a Waiver: Protect Against Liability for NEGLIGENCE!!!

By Doyice Cotten Nicholas Blakely played varsity football for Stetson University. One day, he removed himself from practice complaining that he did not feel well. He was examined by a student trainer and told to stay in the shade. After about 45 minutes he collapsed and died later after being transported to the hospital. Suit against Stetson led to the trial court granting a summary judgment to Stetson based on two identical waivers of liability signed by Blakely. ... [read more]