Featured Article:

Two Virginia Courts Admit Redacted Waivers to Show Plaintiff Understood the Risks

By Doyice Cotten

James McConnel was injured while participating in Segway Polo associated with Omni Hotels Management Corp. The issue came up as to the admissibility of the waiver signed by McConnel (McConnel v. Omni Hotels Mgmt. Corp., 2017).  Since prospective waivers of liability are void as against public policy under Virginia law (Hiett v. Lake Barcroft Cmty. Ass’n, Inc., 1992),  Omni asked the court to rule that the “Segway Personal Transporter Tours Liability Release Form” was admissible with all portions relating to waiver of liability for negligence redacted. Omni wished to show that the plaintiff was aware of the risk of the Segway activity.

McConnel argued that the entire document should be ruled inadmissible.  McConnel claimed that presenting “laypersons with documents which they represent to be valid and to have the force of law, when they know they are in fact void and unenforceable” constitutes fraud on the public.  He contended that it would be inadequate to “simply redact certain language from the liability waiver.”

T3696848635_16eef42e87_zhe court held that the argument is simply not supported by the case law; courts have addressed how documents such as the Release should be treated for admissibility purposes. The court looked to the precedent set in Manchanda v. Hays Worldwide, LLC (2015).  The Manchanda court determined that “Virginia public policy will not permit the Court to view those Agreements as decisive evidence that [decedent] expressly assumed the risk of defendants’ negligence;” nonetheless, the court admitted “other parts of the Agreements as evidence of [decedent’s] knowledge of the dangers of scuba diving.”

Risk Management Take-Away

There are two points that the reader should get from these cases. 1) Even in states in which courts or statutes have forbade the enforcement of waivers of liability for negligence, sport, recreation, and fitness enterprises should continue to require waivers of all participants. One never knows when one might be helpful. 2) One should acquire a waiver that fully addresses the assumption of inherent risks. Such a waiver would include:

  • a list of the typical hazards or causes of participant injuries (falls, collisions with others, being struck by a ball or bat);
  •  a list of injuries that can occur in the specific activity including common minor injuries (bruises, sprains), possible major injuries (concussions, torn ACLs, broken arms), and catastrophic injuries (brain injuries, paralysis, death); and
  • an unambiguous statement that the participant understands the risks of the sport and voluntarily assumes all such risks.

Photo Credit: Thanks to nr1 via Flickr.

Read the Article

Recent Articles:

Can One Spouse Sign the Waiver for the Other Spouse?

By Doyice Cotten Often both a husband and a wife attend a sport, recreation, or fitness facility to participate. The business has a requirement that everyone signs a waiver before participating. Is there a problem if one of the couple signs his or her own waiver and then signs the waiver of the spouse? In the 2017 case, Burns v. Parks (2017 Pa. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 4043), Joseph and Dawn Burns entered Sky Zone Indoor Trampoline Park to participate.... [read more]

Risk Management Failures in Massachusetts YMCA Result in Death

By Doyice Cotten Reminder: There is a new Fitness Law Academy Newsletter designed specifically for fitness professionals. It is written by Dr. JoAnn Eickhoff-Shemek, a fitness industry authority. And the best news of all —  its FREE!.    Click here for your free subscription!   djc The last post dealt with a risk management failure resulting in quadriplegia. This post also involves abysmal risk management – this time resulting in the death of a 62-year-old man (Miller v.... [read more]

Risk Management Breaches Result in Tragedy

 By Doyice Cotten This post is a little different from my usual post – not so much about the results of a waiver case as about provider responsibility. I hope this post impresses upon providers of sport, recreation, and fitness activities the idea that having a waiver might reduce the financial risk of the organization, but does not relieve the provider of the responsibility to make every effort to protect the participant against unnecessary risk of injury.... [read more]

The ABCs of Arbitration Agreements in Waivers of Liability  for Sport, Recreation, & Fitness Providers

 The sport, recreation, and fitness provider has long made use of liability waivers for protection from liability for provider negligence. There is a growing trend toward the inclusion of an arbitration agreement within the waiver; however, there is considerable controversy regarding the wisdom of this inclusion. Here, the authors address some of the pros and cons of the arbitration agreement that the provider and his or her counsel should consider in deciding the issue. It may well be that the choice will vary somewhat depending upon the nature of the business entity and the state in which the business is located.... [read more]

South Carolina State Basketball Player Saved by AED

By Doyice Cotten This is not the first time that automated external defibrillators (AED’s) have been discussed in this column. But once again a life has been saved by their use. South Carolina State was playing North Carolina State in basketball when Ty Solomon, a SCS senior collapsed on the sideline. He had played almost four minutes and was rotated out. While resting on the bench he was talking with a teammate, collapsed unconscious, stopped breathing,... [read more]

CPR and AED Trained Athletic Trainers Save Two Collapsed Athletes

By Doyice Cotten Are you prepared for an emergency at your sport, recreation or fitness facility? If a participant collapses during a workout and has no heartbeat, does someone at your facility know what to do? Do you have personnel trained in CPR? Do you have an AED on hand? And someone who in trained to use it? These are all important questions for management at sport, recreation, and fitness facilities. None of us want to stand by and watch someone die who could have been saved!... [read more]